Native Americans And State Taxes: Not For The Faint Of Heart

  • by:
  • Source: Forbes
  • 04/16/2021
Tax cases involving Native Americans are complex, highly fact-intensive, and if required, a court must weigh the competing interests of the tribe, the federal government, and the state to determine if the tax stands or falls. 

There are instances in which a court, in order to reach the correct result, must examine the original treaty document between the tribe and the United States, all of which were executed well over a century ago. 

Indeed, Congress ended treaty making in 1871, when it passed a rider in a Native American appropriations bill, stating that “no Indian nation or tribe . . . shall be acknowledged or recognized as an independent nation, tribe, or power with whom the United States may contract by treaty . . .” 

Since then, Native American affairs have been regulated through federal legislation which, unlike treaty making, does not require the consent of the tribe or tribes involved.
The fundamental rule governing state taxation regarding Native Americans is simple enough. Without express congressional authorization, a state is powerless to tax Native American reservation lands, enrolled members of the tribe which occupies that land (whether income or excise taxes), and income derived from the land, whether retained by the tribe or distributed to individuals.

Whether a state tax is valid depends upon the person or entity that bears the legal incidence of the tax. Regarding excise taxes, a state tax is per se invalid if the legal incidence falls on the tribe or tribal members. If, however, the legal incidence of the excise tax falls on a non-Native contractor, the tax stands.

One other source of state tax preemption should be mentioned: the Indian Trader statutes. The first statute was enacted in 1790 and reenacted periodically by successive Congresses until it was made permanent in 1834. 

Today, the law requires non-Native persons and businesses to obtain a license from the Bureau of Indian Affairs before entering into commercial relations with the tribes. The Supreme Court has ruledthat a state cannot impose tax on revenues earned by a non-Native trader operating on tribal lands because such traders are federally licensed and subject to extensive federal regulations.

However, a state can require a non-Native trader to collect and remit cigarette taxes from non-tribal member purchasers.

Beyond this fundamental rule and the Indian Trader statutes, the tax waters become deep and murky, partly because U.S. Supreme Court precedent in this area has been anything but clear. Thus, probing further into the permutations and nuances of the law is far beyond the scope of this article.
by is licensed under

Help FAIRtax Become The Number One Issue in 2024

Enacting the FAIRtax must be a prominent topic in these times. We did it before, we can do it again, but we need your help!

Help out with a One-Time Contribution

Your gift of $25, $50, $100 – even $1,000 or more if you can possibly spare it – will help FAIRtax.org bring an end to the IRS and promote a FAIRtax. So, I urge you, please give as generously as you can.

Billing information (REQUIRED)

Payment information (REQUIRED)

To donate by check:
Americans for Fair Taxation
PO Box 4929
Clearwater, FL 33758

If you need to make changes to your existing Monthly Re-Occurring Donation with new card or billing address information, then Please call Adam Yomtov our New York State Co-Director. He is assisting with the administration of our donations, technology services, and website.

Please note: Inputting your new information at our website won't update your donation. The only way to update is by calling Adam Yomtov 917-689-3931 mobile.


Americans for Fair Taxation® is a 501(c)(4) non-profit, non-partisan grassroots organization solely dedicated to replacing the current income tax system with a fair, simple and transparent national consumption tax – the FAIRtax® Plan. We rely entirely on contributions from concerned citizens like you who want a tax system that will generate jobs and stimulate the economy. Welcome to the FAIRtax team!

Connect

Share